Critical Analysis #1 |
![]() ![]() |
Articulation |
![]() ![]() ![]() |
warmhrt Senior Member
since 1999-12-18
Posts 1563![]() |
she knocked lightly, in trepidation, for, though often in each others' company, she'd not been here before. the door opened slowly, he spoke her name as though he'd never voiced it, reading her face, as she stood in the doorway, gazing at him, enveloped in the amazement of just being there, when, suddenly, she realized the chronic ache within her breast had been replaced with a throbbing surge of warmth. he reached out, took her hand, guided her through the doorway till they stood so close they could hear each other breathing. the space between them, which had troubled her so, liquefied as the two lovers stood face to face. the front of his finger brushed lightly down her cheek, ever so slowly, his eyes imaging words she'd seen before, but which now were three-dimensional. her own eyes echoed the mirrored image, as his hands floated in continuous freeze-frame to her neck, to her shoulders, down her sides, sliding glibly around her waist, pulling her close, into a kiss of exquisite articulation. one that could never have fit onto a screen. mia [This message has been edited by miapoetess (edited 11-01-2000).] |
||
© Copyright 2000 warmhrt - All Rights Reserved | |||
Elyse Member
since 2000-04-16
Posts 414Apex (think raleigh) NC |
sigh. mia, this is beautiful. to critique.... he ran the front of his finger choose a more descriptive verb, and her own eyes echoed in kind, i wouldnt use "in kind" thats all for now. fabulous job ![]() luv Elyse |
||
kid D Member
since 2000-10-18
Posts 64 |
ok, lol to critique this...first my heart would have to stop pounding so hard i could hear myself think... this is beautiful...the stuff internet dreams are made of... the first verse is perfect, love it...the way you phrase it is so perfect for, though often in each others' company, she'd not been here before. the chronic ache within her breast had been replaced with a throbbing surge of warmth. the space between them, which had troubled her so, liquefied his eyes imaging words she'd seen before, but which now were three-dimensional. pulling her close, into a kiss of exquisite articulation. one that could never have fit onto a screen. sorry to almost paste the whole poem, but the above lines are perfect...I have never come to this point, past internet friendship..but like i said, this is what dreams are made of...really loved this mia ![]() [This message has been edited by kid D (edited 11-01-2000).] |
||
warmhrt Senior Member
since 1999-12-18
Posts 1563 |
Elyse, I'll think about those suggestions you made, and thank you for reading. I'm so glad you enjoyed this...looks like it's one of those poems women relate to better than guys. Too romantic for them, I guess, huh? kid D, I've never experienced this either...it is the stuff of dreams and imagination. You were sweet to be so generous with your praise. Glad you enjoyed, too. luv ya both, mia ...got to be somewhere better than in the middle...~Wallflowers |
||
Not A Poet Member Elite
since 1999-11-03
Posts 3885Oklahoma, USA |
Hi Mia, I suppose this might be more of a "women's poem" but I still find that I can relate to it. Had to read it more than once to really absorb the impact and each time I do, it feels and becomes more personal. Before I say any more, I remind you that free verse is not my forte ![]() This gave me an image of a secret romance, probably forbidden, perhaps both are married? Well, maybe not. Maybe I put too much into it but that's the impression I get. I suppose some could argue that it reads a little too much like a romance novel but I think you have held back just enough to not fall into that category. Well, anyway, I liked it even if none of the other guys step up here. Thanks, Pete |
||
warmhrt Senior Member
since 1999-12-18
Posts 1563 |
Thank you so much, Pete...you are more of a man than all of them...willing to admit to some of the same feelings we fairer? sex have, and to articulate them, not disguise them within undecipherable language. I was not aware that you were not a free verser, but now that I think of it, the couple of works I've read have been structured...and very well done. You are right about the finger...too late for me to edit, though. Would it be the "upper half of the outside of his finger"? Perhaps I should just say "his finger"...the former sounds quite awkward. Thank you, Pete, again, for being so brave. mia ...got to be somewhere better than in the middle...~Wallflowers |
||
Not A Poet Member Elite
since 1999-11-03
Posts 3885Oklahoma, USA |
Whew . . . (stands up straight, sucks it in and smooths his remaining hair while trying to look nonchalant) Well, I guess you told them. Not sure though that I would do too much with the finger thing, maybe just tip of his finger. It's an important enough piece of the picture but you don't want to overly emphasize it. BTW, I forgot to say that I loved your closing line. That's really a great description for a kiss. Pete |
||
Poertree Senior Member
since 1999-11-05
Posts 1359UK |
sheeeesh she's doing it again I just KNOW she is ...and i’m falling for it again ..but i cant help it ... ![]() quote: EXCUSE ME Ms Mia ..ever heard of busy? ever heard of work? ..or offline?...or people who post long poems that need thorough reading before critiquing? ...geez ![]() ![]() ![]() I'll have you know that Golden Boy Pete does not have a monopoly in simulated feminine feelings .......er ...... I mean genuine romantic deep felt feelings .....lol .. actually i wanted to spend a while looking at this but no time now. just to say that despite the terrific handicap of my maleness i actually loved the whole atmosphere of this poem although i might tinker with the wording in some places. I have one “complaint” which is that the theme isn’t new - you achieve your effect not with surprises or “movement” or innovation but purely and simply by trying to involve the emotions of the reader in the experience - all credit to you therefore that you’ve mostly carried it off successfully - I’ll eat my hat though if you can keep doing it over and over and still hold my attention ......lol the other small thing was that i didn’t like “glibly” ...i know that strictly it can mean ease and informality, but it has, where i come from at least, strong tones of insincerity or even deceit or at the very least lack of depth. Starting to know your writing i guess you’ve chosen it deliberately in what might appear a rather strange usage to describe hand movement because its more common usage (glib words or writing) resonates with their earlier form of communication. All the same though its connotations are all wrong for me. But anyway, these are trivialities, a beautiful poem in many ways mia. And if you’d care to dish out your e-mail address sometime I’ll prove i have a heart by sending some lurve poems ..and no I am not posting them on the forum ...lol ...and no it wasn’t a proposition..... (just a ploy to get your e-mail addr.....heh) ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() take care philip |
||
YeshuJah Malikk Member
since 2000-06-29
Posts 263 |
mia, this is haunting. Haunting, to me, because it seems written from the perspective of the female party here. I find it interesting because it reveals so much about the different ways we think, or see things (male/female). My one nit, which I never seem to be able to coherently explain, is what hits me as the lack of connectivity and flow in the progression of the character's thought process as revealed here. An example: 'as she stood in the doorway, gazing at him, enveloped in the amazement of just being there, when, suddenly, she realized the chronic ache within her breast had been replaced with a throbbing surge of warmth' The word suddenly jerks me here. Up until this point I'm pretty much reading this with my mouth open like a bass on land, my mind is in a hush, then 'suddenly' I find it hard to believe that the character, who is absolutely engrossed in this moment, can divest herself enough to make this observation. I don't know that I am making myself clear here, but what I think has to happen to sustain the power of this, is to keep both reader and character in the same mind set. That this is probably the most lengthy critique I have written about a poem on this forum, is testament to how much it captivated me. This has great appeal. Glad you posted it. |
||
jbouder Member Elite
since 1999-09-18
Posts 2534Whole Sort Of Genl Mish Mash |
Mia: This is not just a simple romantic poem (even though the format is a little simple). My guess is that this is a meeting of people who met on-line. There is much that is left untold here. Are they married? The knock on the door suggests that they have never met in person and I get the picture that the first meeting was at a hotel. At any rate, you've left enough out of the poem that I don't know whether to be happy for the couple or concerned for the woman. Nice job at holding my attention through the poem and developing the theme. Jim |
||
warmhrt Senior Member
since 1999-12-18
Posts 1563 |
PT, I apologize for having taken you (the reader) along for the ride ![]() ![]() ![]() It seems to me that you know the meaning of the wors "glib" very well, and use it in the British connotation in your entire reply. ![]() Now, in re to your request, I must say, PT, that I don't know you very well, and am hesitant. I will think on it. Thank you for reading the poem, and producing such a fine, if not glib, response. ![]() Yesh, You had some good suggestions, and I will surely consider them. I had to laugh a little at the image of a fish with it's mouth agape, reading poetry. ![]() ![]() Jim, I was told that I should call you that...hope it's OK. Thank you, and I think this poem has no surprises...it is one of imagery and emotion alone. It could be about any couple anywhere that first met online, except that there would have been some "space" ie distance, mileage, between them. They know everything there is to know about one another, and their love is true and deep...this is just the first time they've met. That is what I meant to convey...but I suppose I failed if you were worried for the woman. This is definitely not a slam, but you seem to be all business (except in past threads I've read). Am I correct, or are you maybe a little shy? Anyway, thanks for reading my little poem, and also for your commentary. ![]() mia ...got to be somewhere better than in the middle...~Wallflowers |
||
Poertree Senior Member
since 1999-11-05
Posts 1359UK |
quote: hmmm... so there is a distinction, a nuance of meaning, between the US and the UK then i guess... ok, fair enough. quote: yep, risky business disseminating e-mail addresses ![]() ![]() oh and one other thing ... Jim ...SHY!!! ![]() ![]() take care PT |
||
jbouder Member Elite
since 1999-09-18
Posts 2534Whole Sort Of Genl Mish Mash |
Mia: Shy? lol. Never thought about it much. Maybe. As to being "all business", I suppose I am the one who puts Anal in Critical Analysis. ![]() ![]() ![]() Later. Jim |
||
![]() ![]() |
⇧ top of page ⇧ |
![]() ![]() ![]() |
All times are ET (US). All dates are in Year-Month-Day format. |