»
Archives
»
Critical Analysis #2
»
Astronomical Echoes
| Critical Analysis #2 |
|
Astronomical Echoes |
|
|
PoeticJustice Junior Member
since 2002-11-29
Posts 44AK, USA |
Eh, this one's just weird... I expect bad criticism for this one. Let's just say I wasn't all myself when I wrote this. Astronomical Echoes Wandering, wavering, in the sky the clouds watch all that passes by the sun speaks softly in their ears of times of old and star-shed tears. Sadly now the time is gone for the stars to play upon the dawn and when the stars wither and die nothing thing will remain, only a lie. Echoes of the past are here soon everything will disappear the memories that will remain well be saved so, but in vain. Repercussions of the light at hand the sparkle travels far across the land but when the time to judge is near the universe will not be so clear. |
||
| © Copyright 2002 Joshua Carter - All Rights Reserved | |||
|
hush Senior Member
since 2001-05-27
Posts 1653Ohio, USA |
'Let's just say I wasn't all myself when I wrote this.' What do you mean? Were you high? Do you have multiple personality disorder? It bugs me when people drop hints like that but don't say what they mean. 'Wandering, wavering, in the sky the clouds watch all that passes by' I like these two lines. The first line has good alliteration and flow going for it (but I'd eliminate the socond comma). The second line is really cool, because it completely reverses typical human perceptions of the clouds moving- here, they are stationary, and we're what goes by... I think this poem would be really good if you stuck by this idea. 'the sun speaks softly in their ears of times of old and star-shed tears.' Here you begin to deviate from where you began. Your interesting idea becomes a set up for something about time passing.... okay, not sure I like it, but let's see where it goes. 'Sadly now the time is gone for the stars to play upon the dawn and when the stars wither and die nothing thing will remain, only a lie.' What are you talking about? I like the second line, the image is nice- but what does any of this ahve to do with clouds and the sun and times of old? Are you switching suddenly to night, which is turning into morning, which is what you mean by the stars withering and dying? If so, why the abrupt change? And, most of all, what 'lie' will remain? I'm lost. 'Echoes of the past are here soon everything will disappear the memories that will remain well be saved so, but in vain.' What are you talking about? 'Repercussions of the light at hand the sparkle travels far across the land but when the time to judge is near the universe will not be so clear.' What are you talking about? Time to judge? Huh? This poem falls victim to a rhyme scheme that seems to murder your intent and meaning. I don't know how you got from point A to point B. Clarity is a definite issue here, and so is coherence. I am completely lost by this. Hope I've helped. |
||
|
arthur Senior Member
since 2001-08-14
Posts 678england |
I think you have a talent there is a damd good poem here waiting to get out sound idea and some nice images It needs tightening. My aim( and I fail) is to get the best image /statement I can with the least words whilst trying to keep a structure of sounds there is no punctuation However If you wrote it for yourself what the hell but if you wrote it for me Then I want you to work harder !!! arthur ps if I thought it was rubbish then i would have not written or just said a platitude |
||
|
PoeticJustice Junior Member
since 2002-11-29
Posts 44AK, USA |
Ok first I would like to say, in response to you asking me what those stanzas were about, I have no clue whatsoever. No, I was not high, no, I don't have multiple personality disorder(that'd be cool, though, never be lonely). To tell the truth I don't remember very well... I think it was late at night, and I might have been on some cold medicine, but I'm not sure. I was in one of those states where you can just space out for a couple hours and not notice it go by... Almost a trance like state. I had Meddle playing in the cd player and the rhythm is that of Echoes... I think. Might only seem that way to me. Anyways, I'll try to make sense of what's going on... "Wandering, wavering, in the sky the clouds watch all that passes by the sun speaks softly in their ears of times of old and star-shed tears." I personified the the layers of space as we know it(our atmoshpere, the sun, stars, etc.). Maybe the universe or galaxy is a living entity(that's a neat thought...) and it's had wars with itself in the past or something. "Sadly now the time is gone for the stars to play upon the dawn and when the stars wither and die nothing thing will remain, only a lie." Wait, maybe this is about the universe collapsing and something happening in the nothingness(heaven?). Ok this makes no sense now... I tried :p I just posted this here to see if you guys could make any sense of it... I have another one just like this and I really think it's weird. [This message has been edited by PoeticJustice (12-08-2002 04:43 AM).] |
||
|
|
⇧ top of page ⇧ |
|
| All times are ET (US). All dates are in Year-Month-Day format. | ||
