well I have noticed most of the icons are very cartoonish, so it's difficult to select an icon for a serious type of person. Perhaps we should look at the most popular icons, and try to expand a bit on those themes? For example I know a LOT of people use this one because they want to come off as a dark poet, but that icon still looks very cartoonish and halloween-decorationish...
I mean, we have a great selection of icons, sure... but it could be so much better. Let's be honest, there are a lot of icons that nobody uses simply because they are unappealing, too cartoonish or whatever. Then there are so many that would be leapt upon... icons are an important part of PIP, they're how you remember a poet (I'm so glad nobody uses mine ). As PIP grows, and it has been doing this, so too should our bay of icons...
You eat the brains of an old, wise man.