Member Rara Avis
Just as a followup, Auguste emailed me his symptoms and the solution was fairly simple. He was still trying to post in Open Poetry #8, even though we had moved on to #9. That's why he could comment, but not start a new thread.
I don't really know, but I suspect part of his problem was bookmarking #8 and going directly there without first seeing the main page. Ergo, he never saw the new OP #9.
Do NOT Bookmark Forums
There are only three pages you can safely use to enter the forums. The main page, where all the forums are listed, your Personal Library page, and the Logon page. Those three will recognize a new visit from you and set your cookies accordingly. Other pages, including the individual forums, won't.