navwin » Archives » Critical Analysis #1 » paste and scissors
Critical Analysis #1
Post A Reply Post New Topic paste and scissors Go to Previous / Newer Topic Back to Topic List Go to Next / Older Topic
russelle
Junior Member
since 1999-11-02
Posts 21
Chicago, Il. USA

0 posted 1999-11-03 04:43 PM


My left hand holds fast my flailing jacket
Like a child gripping his favorite blanket.
Soon it begins to numb as it absorbs the frigid wind intended for my body.
My right hand warms in my pocket,
Waiting its turn to brave the elements.

The red YMCA sign alerts me that my journey is almost through
And I return my eyes to the pavement
My eyes are torn from the pavement
Not by wind, but by the rattle of coins in a plastic cup
I squint against the wind to see
Tattered gloves
Torn pockets
Missing buttons
All serving to cover what looked like a man

A quivering plea?
A helpless gaze?
A farfetched story?
What awaited me at the light

“Man, I gotta get some shelter Its freezing
I got nothing, I just want to get warm
To get on the ell a bus anything I need some warmth”
Fumbling with the keys and mints in my pocket I shovel out
Two quarters
And a dime
“Sorry man, its all I got” somehow slips from my chapping lips
The light turns, and I switch hands

As I plod on my eyes are once more ripped from the cracking sidewalk
This time by thoughts
Which rattle back and forth in my head like the coins in his plastic cup
Who? who did I just pass?
Surely he was once a man like me
Once he too dreamt of more than simply warmth
He once worked
Slept in a home
Spoke to a friend
Talked on the phone
Held a girls hand
OH GOD, HOW DOES HE WARM HIS HANDS NOW?

He never
Asked
Desired
Dreamed
Of this
No, he dreamed of much much more
He dreamed of money, joy and peace
He dreamed of a family
A wife
A child
Grandchildren?

But now, now his dreams have shriveled up like newspaper in a burn barrel,
They have cracked as cheap upholstery left to long in the glaring sun,
They have shattered like an icicle falling from a thawing gutter,
They have been swallowed up and forgotten
Like the once enlivening contents of his plastic cup.
Leaving him alone with his
Tattered gloves
Torn pockets
Missing buttons
Two quarters
And a dime

His life has become a dreamless nightmare
From which he may never awake
And in which he cannot sleep.

Dependent upon chance passerbyers
He is left with one burning desire:
Warmth

GOD SURELY THIS COLD DESTROYS MORE THEN JUST THE PAVEMENT
BUT AT LEAST THE PAVEMENT, ITS POTHOLES, THEY WILL SOON BE
FILLED
BUT WHO WILL FILL THIS MAN, WHILE MAN HE STILL IS

Soon I find myself standing outside my dorm room fumbling for my keys
A cool draft blows upon my thawing feet.
I open the door to a great breeze
Papers fluttering, shades flapping against the window frame
I run over to shut the window.
Shutting out the frigid wind
I crawl into bed and in that moment I have all that man desires,
Warmth

But I am not happy, I want more
I deserve more, right?
My desires continue to swirl like that frigid wind
Uncontained.

Throwing off the covers I hit my knees
OH GOD, GOD THAT YOU WOULD SHUT THE EARTH’S WINDOW
SHUT THE WINDOW AND GIVE THAT MAN WARMTH
AND SHUT THE WINDOW OF MY MIND
WHOSE DESIRES KNOW NO BOUNDARIES
I pray, oh how I pray

The plastic cup falls to the ground,
The change lands deftly on the snow.
Blood oozes from a forgotten head
Contaminating the fresh snow
Before freezing upon the curb
And my head hits upon a soft pillow
Basking in warmth
Before dreaming of
More friends
More fun
And how I deserve it.

Rising once again
I go to take my shower.
And his broken body which will never rise again
Is dragged off of the street
To be put together with paste and scissors
Out of old clippings
No one would take the trouble to make an article

© Copyright 1999 russelle - All Rights Reserved
Brad
Member Ascendant
since 1999-08-20
Posts 5705
Jejudo, South Korea
1 posted 1999-11-04 03:19 AM


I must say that I think this is a very good poem, great images and many strong points. However, it does seem a little scattered. Wondering if you might want to clean it up a bit:

stanza 1: very good
stanza 2: very good
stanza 3: don't think you need it
stanza 4: works well with stanza 2 so I don't think you need 3.

stanzas 5-10: Here I think you've moved away from showing a scene to talking, thinking about the scene. If you want to keep this stuff in there, why not create a dialogue?
Drop all the dream stuff.

stanza 11: back in form. Well done.
stanza 12: seems too blunt, try to suggest this feeling more subtly.

stanza 13-14:I got confused here. How does the character know this is going on if he's home?

last stanza: you've got an interesting parallel thing going there but maybe you should have begun with that or at least made it more clear.

Just some suggestions.

Still enjoyed the poem very much.
Thanks for the read,
Brad

russelle
Junior Member
since 1999-11-02
Posts 21
Chicago, Il. USA
2 posted 1999-11-04 09:20 AM


thanks so much brad, thats the kind of stuff i was looking for, i will try and clean it up a little, apreciate the citique.
russelle

haze
Senior Member
since 1999-11-03
Posts 528
Bethlehem, PA USA
3 posted 1999-11-04 09:38 AM


Brad covered all of the points (and then some) so I just need to tell you...I truly enjoyed the read, the images and messages.
Post A Reply Post New Topic ⇧ top of page ⇧ Go to Previous / Newer Topic Back to Topic List Go to Next / Older Topic
All times are ET (US). All dates are in Year-Month-Day format.
navwin » Archives » Critical Analysis #1 » paste and scissors

Passions in Poetry | pipTalk Home Page | Main Poetry Forums | 100 Best Poems

How to Join | Member's Area / Help | Private Library | Search | Contact Us | Login
Discussion | Tech Talk | Archives | Sanctuary